
In T 0942/25 of 8 July 2026, Technical Board of Appeal (TBA) of the European Patent Office dismissed Beijing Zitiao’s appeal concerning an audio-preview method. For assessment of inventive step, the TBA’s reasoning distinguishes information about content consumption from information assisting a user in performing a technical task. This distinction may be important to take into account when drafting patent applications directed to (graphical) user interfaces.
Background and distinguishing features
Claim 1 of Beijing Zitiao’s patent application required a segmented progress bar for audio-preview clips, showing played progress in black and unplayed progress in grey. The applicant argued that these features simplified operation and improved speed and efficiency.
Prior-art document D3 (US 2007/0061497 A1) already described automatic preview playback triggered by the position of a cursor within a list of recordings. The TBA found that D3’s played and unplayed bar portions satisfied the segmentation requirement, because claim 1 of Beijing Zitiao’s application did not require different segments to represent different clips. According to the TBA, claim 1 of Beijing Zitiao’s application only differed from D3 in that the bar is displayed during preview and that the color grey is used for unplayed progress.
Presentation or technical assistance?
The applicable test asks whether a graphical user interface (GUI), together with its content and manner of presentation, credibly assists the user in performing a technical task through continued and/or guided human–machine interaction. The purpose of presenting the information is therefore central. According to the TBA, displaying information on a technical apparatus does not, by itself, establish a technical contribution.
In Beijing Zitiao’s application, playback progress “located” the listener within the content, rather than indicating a condition relevant to the apparatus’s technical functioning. The TBA concluded that listening is content consumption, and that the distinguishing features therefore did not support the required interaction process.
The TBA also recalled that ergonomic improvements in GUI design remain non-technical without a tangible and credible technical effect beyond the GUI. Claims of easier, faster or more efficient interface operation therefore cannot replace identifying the relevant technical effect without further plausible explanation.
Outcome and implications
Without a technical effect across the claim’s scope, the distinguishing features did not enter the inventive-step assessment. According to the TBA, claim 1 of Beijing Zitiao’s application therefore lacked inventive step over D3.
For GUI or presentation features relying on assistance with a technical task, the current reasoning of the TBA underlines the need to identify that technical task and explain how the claimed presentation features support or improve that technical task. Greater clarity of presentation is not, by itself, that explanation. A distinction should be made between (A) making information easier to understand and (B) enabling the user to carry out a technical activity through the claimed interaction. According to the present decision of the TBA, the latter is actually decisive for patentability.

